↓Skip to main content

Your Top Withholding Agent Client Withheld 1% Instead of 2%: What Goes in Your SAWT DAT File?

When a Top Withholding Agent (TWA) client withheld the wrong rate, your SAWT DAT file still reports only what the BIR Form 2307 shows: the income payment printed on it and the tax actually withheld. RR No. 2-98 Section 2.57.2(I) sets 1% for goods and 2% for services, but a certificate showing 1% on a service gives you a credit of 1%, not 2%.

Match Every Certificate to Its SAWT Row FREE →

This guide is for suppliers whose clients are Top Withholding Agents. It covers what to do when the rate or ATC on a certificate does not fit the payment, and how the SAWT (Summary Alphalist of Withholding Tax) stays equal to the credit you claim. It belongs to the SAWT series and the BIR Form 2307 series.

What rates does a Top Withholding Agent apply to suppliers? #

A Top Withholding Agent withholds 1% on income payments to suppliers of goods and 2% on income payments to suppliers of services, for regular suppliers and for any single purchase of ₱10,000 or more. The rule sits in Section 2.57.2(I) of Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 2-98, as renumbered and amended by RR No. 11-2018.

Section 2.57.2(I), as amended by RR No. 11-2018, provides:

“Income payments made by any of the top withholding agents, as determined by the Commissioner, to their local/resident supplier of goods/services, including non-resident aliens engaged in trade or business in the Philippines, shall be subjected to the following withholding tax rates: Supplier of goods – One percent (1%) Supplier of services – Two percent (2%)”

The same subsection says “goods” means “tangible personal property” and that a single purchase of “Ten thousand pesos (₱10,000) or more shall be subject to withholding tax under this subsection.” For the payor side, see BIR Form 2307 for TWA purchases of goods and for services.

Why does the wrong rate show up on a BIR Form 2307? #

The wrong rate usually appears because the client’s accounting system applies one ATC to a whole vendor, while the supplier sells both goods and services. A vendor tagged “goods” gets 1% on a service invoice; a vendor tagged “services” gets 2% on a delivery. The error is the payor’s, but the certificate you hold carries it.

Mixed invoices make it worse. A single invoice that bundles goods and installation can legitimately split between ATCs; see mixed goods and services under BIR Form 2307 for how the split works. Whether a particular payment is “goods” or “services” is a classification question for you and the payor, not something your SAWT can settle.

What must your SAWT DAT file match? #

Your SAWT must match the BIR Form 2307 certificates behind your credit, and the credit you claim on the return must equal the SAWT total. RR No. 2-2006 builds validation around that equality, so a row cannot carry a rate or an amount different from the certificate it represents.

Section 2.D of RR No. 2-2006 lists the returns that need the SAWT, among them BIR Form 1701Q, BIR Form 1702Q, and BIR Form 2550Q, and states:

“The validation of e-filed returns shall ensure that the total amounts claimed as creditable tax withheld in the return must have the corresponding attached SAWT reflecting total amounts which is equal to the total amounts claimed as credits.”

The practical result: the SAWT row mirrors the certificate. Do not “fix” the ATC or the withheld amount in the DAT file to what the rate table says. The row-by-row mechanics are in How to build a SAWT DAT file from BIR Form 2307 certificates.

Worked example: a supplier of goods and services to one Top Withholding Agent #

In this fictional third-quarter example, one certificate is right, one is wrong, and the SAWT carries both exactly as printed. Lumina Print Supplies Corp. sells paper to a Top Withholding Agent and also designs packaging for it. All figures are invented for illustration.

InvoiceNatureIncome paymentRate that should applyCertificate showsTax withheld on certificate
Paper deliveryGoods₱300,0001%ATC WC158, 1%₱3,000
Packaging designServices₱150,0002% = ₱3,000ATC WC158, 1%₱1,500

The client applied the goods code to the design fee. The SAWT then reads:

SAWT rowATCIncome paymentTax withheld
1WC158₱300,000₱3,000
2WC158₱150,000₱1,500
Total₱450,000₱4,500

Lumina claims ₱4,500 on its BIR Form 1702Q. It does not claim ₱6,000, the tax that 2% on services would have produced, because ₱1,500 was never withheld or certified. It asks the client for a corrected BIR Form 2307 for the design fee. If the client withholds and remits the shortfall, the new certificate shows the extra tax and the SAWT is updated for the corrected certificate. The ATC codes shown (WC158 for 1% goods, WC160 for 2% services) are those in the BIR’s ATC table as used on this site; confirm the code on your own certificate.

What should you do when the certificate is wrong? #

Ask the payor to issue a corrected BIR Form 2307, keep the original, and reflect only certified amounts in the SAWT until the corrected one arrives. The payor controls the withholding and the certificate; you control the accuracy of your claim.

  1. Compare each certificate to the invoice: goods or services, amount, and rate.
  2. Send the payor a written request for a corrected certificate, citing the invoice number.
  3. Enter the certificate as printed in the SAWT for the period if you must file before the correction arrives.
  4. When the corrected certificate comes, follow Amending a SAWT After a Corrected Certificate.
  5. If a certificate never arrives, use What to do when a BIR Form 2307 is missing or late.

Reconcile each quarter with SAWT reconciliation against BIR Form 2307 so mismatches surface before the return is filed.

Frequently Asked Questions #

What do I put in my SAWT when a Top Withholding Agent withheld 1% on my services instead of 2%? #

Enter the income payment and the tax withheld exactly as printed on the BIR Form 2307 you received. RR No. 2-2006 requires the creditable tax claimed on the return to equal the total on the attached SAWT, so you cannot claim the 2% you believe was due when the certificate shows only 1%.

What rates does a Top Withholding Agent apply to suppliers? #

RR No. 2-98 Section 2.57.2(I), as amended by RR No. 11-2018, sets 1% on income payments to suppliers of goods and 2% on income payments to suppliers of services. The rule covers regular suppliers and any single purchase of ₱10,000 or more.

Should I change the ATC in my SAWT to the one I think is correct? #

No. Each SAWT row carries the ATC printed on the certificate it represents. If the code or rate on the certificate is wrong, ask the payor for a corrected BIR Form 2307 and update the SAWT only after the corrected certificate arrives.

Can I claim the unwithheld difference as a credit on my income tax return? #

No. A creditable withholding tax credit exists only for tax actually withheld and certified. The difference was never withheld, so it is not a credit, and it stays part of your income tax due on the return.

Do I need to amend a SAWT already filed if the corrected BIR Form 2307 arrives later? #

If the corrected certificate changes an amount you already claimed, the credit and the SAWT must be brought back in line. See the guide on amending a SAWT after a corrected certificate for the sequence of steps.

Summary #

A Top Withholding Agent withholds 1% on goods and 2% on services under RR No. 2-98 Section 2.57.2(I), as amended by RR No. 11-2018. When the certificate shows the wrong rate, the SAWT still mirrors the certificate, because RR No. 2-2006 ties the credit claimed on the return to the SAWT total. Claim what was certified, ask for a corrected BIR Form 2307, and amend once it arrives. See the BIR Form 2307 hub for the full series.