↓Skip to main content

Selling Property Under BIR Distraint or Refusing to Surrender It: Penalties Under NIRC Sections 276 and 277

NIRC Section 276 punishes a taxpayer who sells, transfers or encumbers property placed under constructive distraint without the Commissioner’s knowledge and consent, and Section 277 makes any person holding distrained property liable for its value if the person refuses to surrender it on demand. Both are criminal provisions on top of the tax itself, so they matter to owners, bank officers and tenants who hold a debtor’s assets.

Stay Out of Collection: Check Your Filings Before the BIR Does FREE →

What does Section 276 say? #

Section 276 targets the taxpayer whose property is under constructive distraint and who tries to move it. It reads:

“Any taxpayer, whose property has been placed under constructive distraint, who sells, transfers, encumbers or in any way disposes of said property, or any part thereof, without the knowledge and consent of the Commissioner, shall, upon conviction for each act or omission, be punished by a fine of not less than twice the value of the property so sold, encumbered or disposed of but not less than Five Thousand pesos (P5,000), or suffer imprisonment of not less than two (2) years and one (1) day but not more than four (4) years, of both.”

Source: NIRC Section 276, Republic Act No. 8424 on LawPhil (the LawPhil text reads “of both,” apparently for “or both”). How constructive distraint works is in Constructive Distraint Under Section 206.

What does Section 277 say? #

Section 277 binds third parties who hold property under a warrant. The provision states:

“Any person having in his possession or under his control any property or rights to property, upon which a warrant of constructive distraint, or actual distraint and levy has been issued shall, upon demand by the Commissioner or any of his deputies executing such warrant, surrender such property or right to property to the Commissioner or any of his deputies, unless such property or right is, at the time of such demand, subject to an attachment or execution under any judicial process.”

Failing to surrender makes the person “liable in his own person and estate to the Government in a sum equal to the value of the property or rights not so surrendered but not exceeding the amount of the taxes (including penalties and interest) for the collection of which such warrant had been issued, together with cost and interest if any,” plus “a fine of not less than Five thousand pesos (P5,000), or … imprisonment of not less than six (6) months and one (1) day but not more than two (2) years, or both.”

Source: NIRC Section 277, same LawPhil text. See also Warrant of Distraint and Levy and Garnishment of a Bank Account Under Section 208.

How do the two sections compare? #

Section 276Section 277
Who is liableThe taxpayer whose property is under constructive distraintAnyone holding the property or rights to it
Prohibited actSelling, transferring, encumbering or disposing without Commissioner’s consentFailing or refusing to surrender on demand
Money consequenceFine of at least twice the value, not less than ₱5,000Liability up to the tax due, penalties and interest, up to the property’s value, plus cost and interest
Imprisonment2 years and 1 day to 4 years, or both6 months and 1 day to 2 years, or both
ExceptionCommissioner’s knowledge and consentProperty already under judicial attachment or execution

Worked example: a bank, a delinquent taxpayer and ₱900,000 #

A BIR warrant covers a delinquent taxpayer’s ₱900,000 deposit account. The unpaid tax, penalties and interest total ₱640,000. If the bank refuses the revenue officer’s demand to surrender the funds, and the account is not already subject to a court attachment, Section 277 makes the bank liable up to the lesser of the value not surrendered (₱900,000) and the amount of the tax claim, which here would cap exposure at ₱640,000 plus cost and interest, with the fine or imprisonment attaching to the responsible person. If instead the taxpayer withdrew and spent the money after constructive distraint was placed, Section 276 applies to the taxpayer: a fine of at least twice the amount disposed of (₱1,800,000 on ₱900,000), or imprisonment, or both.

This article did not review court decisions applying the two sections; confirm any case with a tax lawyer.

Summary #

  • Disposing of property under constructive distraint without the Commissioner’s consent is punishable under Section 276.
  • Anyone holding distrained property must surrender it on demand under Section 277, unless a court attachment or execution already covers it.
  • Liability under Section 277 is capped at the tax claim and tied to the property’s value.

FAQ #

Can a taxpayer sell property placed under constructive distraint? #

Not without the knowledge and consent of the Commissioner. NIRC Section 276 punishes a taxpayer who sells, transfers, encumbers or disposes of such property without it, with a fine of not less than twice the value of the property but not less than P5,000, or imprisonment of two years and one day to four years, or both.

Who is liable under Section 277? #

Any person having in possession or control property or rights to property on which a warrant of constructive distraint, or actual distraint and levy, has been issued, if the person fails or refuses to surrender it upon demand by the Commissioner or the deputy executing the warrant.

How much is a person liable for under Section 277? #

A sum equal to the value of the property or rights not surrendered, but not exceeding the taxes, penalties and interest for which the warrant was issued, plus cost and interest, and a fine of not less than P5,000 or imprisonment of six months and one day to two years, or both.

Is there any exception to the duty to surrender? #

Yes. Section 277 does not require surrender if the property or right is, at the time of the demand, subject to an attachment or execution under any judicial process.