↓Skip to main content

Is Withholding Tax Computed on the VAT-Inclusive or VAT-Exclusive Amount? What Goes on BIR Form 2307

·5 mins

When a VAT-registered supplier bills a VAT-inclusive amount, the creditable withholding tax is computed on the amount net of VAT, not on the invoice total. On a ₱112,000 invoice for services at 12% VAT, the base is ₱100,000, so a 2% rate withholds ₱2,000. Revenue Memorandum Circular (RMC) No. 23-2007 states the rule, and BIR Form 2307 should show that net base.

Let the Tool Compute the Base for You — FREE →

This guide belongs to the BIR Form 2307 series. For the rate tables, use the ATC codes guide.

What does RMC No. 23-2007 say about the withholding base? #

RMC No. 23-2007 says the basis of withholding income tax is always net of Value-Added Tax (VAT). The circular, signed by then-Commissioner Jose Mario C. Buñag, is titled “Clarification on the Computations of Withholding Taxes and Other Requirements on Government Money Payments.” Its operative sentence reads:

“The basis of the withholding of income tax should always be net of the Value-Added Tax (VAT)…”

— RMC No. 23-2007, as reproduced at Tax Matters (philtax.blogspot.com)

This quote is taken from a secondary reproduction of the circular, because the BIR’s PDF could not be retrieved while writing; the ellipsis marks where the sentence continues to describe the VAT imposed on the purchase. The circular’s own illustrations are government purchases, so a private withholding agent that wants certainty should confirm treatment with its Revenue District Office (RDO).

How do you back VAT out of a VAT-inclusive invoice? #

Divide the VAT-inclusive total by 1.12 to get the base, then apply the withholding rate to that base. The 12% VAT is already inside the billed amount, so multiplying the total by the rate overstates the tax.

  1. Read the invoice total and confirm the supplier is VAT-registered (the invoice shows VAT separately).
  2. Compute base = total ÷ 1.12.
  3. Compute output VAT = total − base.
  4. Multiply the base by the withholding rate for the income type (see the ATC codes guide).
  5. Pay the supplier the total less the tax withheld.

Worked example: a ₱112,000 services invoice and a ₱56,000 rent invoice #

A VAT-inclusive ₱112,000 services invoice withholds ₱2,000 at 2%; withholding on the full total would wrongly withhold ₱2,240. The RMC’s own example uses a ₱5,600 services invoice (base ₱5,000, VAT ₱600) with 2% income tax of ₱100; the table below scales the same logic to fictional amounts.

LineContractor (2% services)Lessor (5% rent)
Invoice total (VAT-inclusive)₱112,000₱56,000
Withholding base (total ÷ 1.12)₱100,000₱50,000
Output VAT₱12,000₱6,000
Rate applied to base2%5%
Tax withheld (shown on BIR Form 2307)₱2,000₱2,500
Wrong amount if applied to total₱2,240₱2,800
Cash paid to supplier₱110,000₱53,500

On the contractor invoice, the BIR Form 2307 income payment column shows ₱100,000 and the tax withheld shows ₱2,000. The VAT of ₱12,000 is still paid to the supplier because it is not part of the income payment. Rates follow RR No. 2-98 as amended by RR No. 11-2018; see withholding tax on rent for the rent bracket.

What if the supplier is not VAT-registered? #

A non-VAT supplier’s invoice contains no VAT, so the full billed amount is the withholding base. RMC No. 23-2007’s non-VAT illustration applies the income tax rate to the whole ₱1,000 goods invoice and ₱5,000 services invoice, with the 3% percentage tax handled separately as that circular’s example shows.

If a supplier’s invoice does not separate VAT, check its VAT status on the receipt and BIR Certificate of Registration before choosing the base. See the non-VAT payee guide for how non-VAT suppliers receive certificates.

How do you avoid mismatches on BIR Form 2307? #

Show the VAT-exclusive base in the income payment column so the tax withheld equals base × rate. A certificate where the tax does not equal the stated rate times the income payment is the type of mismatch a reviewer flags.

  • Record the base and the VAT separately in your payables ledger.
  • Compute withholding from the base column, never the gross column.
  • Reconcile each quarter’s certificates to your withholding return before issuing them.

Frequently asked questions #

Is the 2% or 5% withholding rate applied to the VAT-inclusive invoice total? #

For a VAT-registered supplier, the income tax withholding base is the invoice amount net of VAT. RMC No. 23-2007 states that the basis of the withholding of income tax should always be net of the Value-Added Tax. On a ₱112,000 VAT-inclusive invoice, the base is ₱100,000 and a 2% rate withholds ₱2,000, not ₱2,240.

How do I back the VAT out of a VAT-inclusive amount? #

Divide the VAT-inclusive total by 1.12 to get the VAT-exclusive base, assuming the standard 12% VAT rate. For ₱112,000, the base is ₱100,000 and the output VAT is ₱12,000. Apply the withholding rate to the ₱100,000.

What amount appears as the income payment on BIR Form 2307? #

The income payment column should show the VAT-exclusive base on which the tax was computed, with the tax withheld next to it. If the certificate shows the VAT-inclusive total beside a 2% tax, the numbers will not reconcile to the rate, and the payee’s credit may be questioned.

Does the same rule apply to a supplier that is not VAT-registered? #

A non-VAT supplier’s invoice carries no VAT, so the full billed amount is the base. RMC No. 23-2007’s own non-VAT illustration applies the income tax rate to the full ₱1,000 goods invoice and ₱5,000 services invoice, with percentage tax handled separately.

Is RMC No. 23-2007 only about government payments? #

The circular’s heading and examples concern computations on government money payments. The net-of-VAT sentence is written as a general basis rule, but because the circular’s illustrations are government purchases, a private withholding agent in doubt should confirm treatment with its Revenue District Office (RDO).

Summary #

For VAT-registered suppliers, divide the invoice by 1.12 and apply the withholding rate to the net base, as RMC No. 23-2007 states. Show that base on BIR Form 2307, pay the VAT to the supplier, and treat a non-VAT supplier’s full invoice as the base.