Erasures and Out-of-Sequence Entries in BIR Books of Accounts: What Is Allowed?
You should not erase entries in a BIR-registered book of accounts, and no BIR provision found for this article prohibits entering a forgotten expense late. NIRC Section 232 requires a journal and a ledger, and RR No. 17-2013 requires books to be kept intact, unaltered, and unmutilated. The practical answer is to leave the wrong entry visible and fix it with a documented correcting entry dated when you post it.
Stop Fixing Ledger Mistakes by Hand: Try the Tools FREE →What do the BIR rules say about how books of accounts are kept? #
The law sets the duty to keep books, not a page-by-page style guide. NIRC Section 232(A) requires taxpayers to keep a journal and a ledger or their equivalents, and Section 233 lets them add subsidiary books such as a cash disbursement book. Subsidiary books fall under the same rules as the journal and the ledger, so a cash disbursement book is a registered book, not scratch paper.
Section 232(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code (as enacted, reproduced on LawPhil) begins:
“All corporations, companies, partnerships or persons required by law to pay internal revenue taxes shall keep a journal and a ledger or their equivalents”
Section 233 then provides that where subsidiary books are kept, “they shall form part of the accounting system of the taxpayer and shall be subject to the same rules and regulations as to their keeping, translation, production and inspection as are applicable to the journal and the ledger.”
Note what the law does not say. For manual books, none of the BIR issuances reviewed for this article state a rule on erasures, ink, strikethroughs, or strict date order. Anyone who quotes a specific “cross out with one line” BIR rule for paper books should be asked for the issuance number.
Can you erase an entry in the cash disbursement book? #
No. An erasure destroys the original record, and the BIR’s preservation rule requires books to be intact and unaltered. Section 1 of Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 17-2013 states the standard that all books, registers, records, vouchers, and supporting papers must be preserved “intact, unaltered, and unmutilated” and kept at the place of business, ready to be produced on demand (wording as reproduced in the Lawyerly copy of the regulation).
The only BIR text found that speaks directly to corrections is RR No. 9-2009 on electronic records. Section 5.5.1 lists controls a taxpayer should have, ending with:
“and controls to ensure there is no accidental or intentional editing or deletion of recorded or completed transactions. Changes to any recorded transaction must be made by journal entry, be adequately documented, and include the following:”
That quote is from RR No. 9-2009, Section 5.5.1, as reproduced on Lawyerly; the regulation then lists what a change record must show. It applies to electronic systems, but it shows how the BIR treats a recorded transaction: it is corrected by a new, documented entry, not by editing or deleting the old one.
Can you enter a forgotten expense out of date order? #
A late entry is allowed in practice; rewriting earlier pages to make it look on time is not. No BIR issuance reviewed here requires manual books to be strictly in date order or bans a late posting. The defensible method is to post the forgotten expense on the next open line, on the date you actually record it, with the original document date and number in the particulars column.
Doing it this way keeps the book’s physical order honest and leaves an audit trail an examiner can follow from the entry to the supporting document. Squeezing the item into a blank line on an earlier page, or backdating it to look original, invites the question of whether the book was written at the time of the transaction.
Whether the expense belongs in a return that has already been filed is a separate tax question. If a forgotten expense belongs to a closed period, ask your accountant whether an amended return is appropriate.
Worked example: a forgotten ₱4,850 expense and a wrong amount #
A sole proprietor with a registered manual cash disbursement book finds two problems at month-end close.
| Problem | Wrong way | Safer way |
|---|---|---|
| ₱4,850 electricity bill paid on October 28 was never recorded | Squeeze it into a blank line on the October 28 page | Record it on the next open line dated November 3 (the date of posting), particulars: “Electricity, OR No. 20931 dated Oct. 28” |
| ₱12,500 supplier payment was recorded as ₱1,250 | Erase the amount and write over it | Leave the ₱1,250 line visible; add a line reversing ₱1,250 and a line recording ₱12,500, both citing the same check voucher number |
The wrong figure stays legible, the correction is dated and explained, and the supporting document ties both lines together. The OR number and amounts above are fictional values for illustration.
How do manual, loose-leaf, and computerized books differ? #
The three formats differ in how they are registered and in how corrections are made, but the principle of no silent overwriting is the same. BIR Books of Accounts: Manual, Loose-Leaf, and Computerized Accounting System Requirements covers the formats in full. The table below isolates what matters for corrections.
| Format | Registration | How a mistake is fixed |
|---|---|---|
| Manual (pre-printed, bound) | RDO | Correcting entries on the next open line; no erasing |
| Permanently bound loose-leaf | Online through ORUS (RMC No. 4-2026) | Correct in the software before printing, or post a correcting entry; do not alter printed pages |
| Computerized | Online through ORUS (RMC No. 4-2026) | Documented journal entry; RR No. 9-2009 Section 5.5.1 expects no editing or deletion of recorded transactions |
RMC No. 4-2026 provides that “the registration of Permanently Bound Loose-Leaf Books of Accounts and Computerized Books of Accounts shall be strictly and mandatorily completed online through ORUS within the prescribed deadlines.” For the extended deadlines, see RMC No. 4-2026: The Extended BIR ORUS Books of Accounts Registration Deadline. Corrections practice for loose-leaf pages in the paragraph above is bookkeeping practice, not a BIR-prescribed procedure.
What is the penalty for improperly kept books? #
RMO No. 7-2015 prices record-keeping violations on a compromise scale from ₱1,000 to ₱50,000, tiered by gross annual sales, earnings, or receipts. Its Annex A has no line item for “erasures.” The nearest lines are failure to keep or preserve records required by law or regulations (NIRC Section 232/235) and failure to keep books or make a true and complete transaction record (Section 257(7)(i)).
| Gross annual sales, earnings, or receipts | Compromise |
|---|---|
| ₱50,000 and below | ₱1,000 |
| ₱50,001 to ₱100,000 | ₱3,000 |
| ₱100,001 to ₱500,000 | ₱5,000 |
| ₱500,001 to ₱5,000,000 | ₱10,000 |
| ₱5,000,001 to ₱10,000,000 | ₱15,000 |
| ₱10,000,001 to ₱20,000,000 | ₱20,000 |
| ₱20,000,001 to ₱50,000,000 | ₱30,000 |
| Over ₱50,000,000 | ₱50,000 |
Source: RMO No. 7-2015 Annex A. For a business with ₱3,200,000 in gross annual sales, the bracket is ₱10,000. Books found at material variance with other books are listed as not compromisable because they involve fraud. See BIR Compromise Penalty for Failure to Keep or Preserve Books of Accounts and Records for the full tables, and note that an ordinary correcting entry with a document trail is not a violation.
Frequently Asked Questions #
Can I erase an entry in my BIR-registered cash disbursement book? #
Erasing is the wrong fix. NIRC Section 232 requires a journal and a ledger that show a true record of transactions, and RR No. 17-2013 requires books to be preserved intact, unaltered, and unmutilated. Instead of erasing, leave the wrong entry legible and correct it with a reversing entry and a new correct entry, each referencing the supporting document.
Is there a BIR rule that says to cross out a wrong entry with a single line? #
No BIR issuance reviewed for this article prescribes a single-line strikethrough for manual books. The regulation that is explicit about corrections, RR No. 9-2009 Section 5.5.1, covers electronic records and requires that changes to a recorded transaction be made by journal entry and be adequately documented. Treating paper books the same way, with a documented correcting entry, is the safest practice.
Can I record a forgotten expense out of date order in my cash disbursement book? #
No BIR provision reviewed for this article forbids a late entry, and none prescribes strict date order for manual books. The safe practice is to record the forgotten expense on the next open line on the date you actually post it, and write the original document date and number in the particulars column. Do not squeeze the entry into an earlier blank space or rewrite earlier pages.
What is the BIR penalty for erasures in books of accounts? #
RMO No. 7-2015 Annex A has no line item for erasures as such. The closest lines are failure to keep or preserve records under NIRC Section 232/235 and failure to make a true and complete transaction record under Section 257(7)(i), both compromised from ₱1,000 to ₱50,000 depending on gross annual sales, earnings, or receipts. Which line applies to a given finding is the revenue officer’s determination.
Are loose-leaf and computerized books treated differently from manual books? #
Yes, in registration and in how corrections happen. Permanently bound loose-leaf books and computerized books must be registered online through ORUS under RMC No. 4-2026, while manual books are registered at the RDO. For computerized books, RR No. 9-2009 Section 5.5.1 expects controls against accidental or intentional editing or deletion of recorded transactions, so corrections are made by documented journal entry.
What should I do if my books already contain erasures or are out of order? #
Do not tear out pages or rewrite the book. Keep the existing pages, add a dated explanatory note and correcting entries going forward, and keep the supporting documents together with the book. Then ask your accountant or Revenue District Office how to treat any entries that affect a return already filed.
Summary #
Do not erase entries in a registered book of accounts. Leave the wrong entry readable and correct it with a documented entry, as RR No. 9-2009 Section 5.5.1 requires for electronic records and RR No. 17-2013 implies for all books through its “intact, unaltered, and unmutilated” standard. A forgotten expense can be posted late on the next open line with the original document reference. Record-keeping failures are compromised under RMO No. 7-2015 from ₱1,000 to ₱50,000. Read BIR Books of Accounts for format requirements and RMC No. 4-2026 for ORUS registration deadlines.